Drunks on bikes

Roger Joys

2006-02-04

Al long as it's in S. Dakota...

I beleive the same DUII laws apply to cyclist on Burnside in Portland as they do to motorists.

I think in Oregon you can be arrested for what sounds like Donald Duck's nephews... HUII, DUII and BUII.
-----Original Message-----
From: oregonyankee@comcast.net [mailto:oregonyankee@comcast.net]
Sent: Saturday, February 4, 2006 08:50 PM
To: cmurray@obra.org, obra@list.obra.org
Subject: Re: [OBRA Chat] Drunks on bikes

So let's all get plastered and weave our bikes down Burnside with impunity! The mind boggles.

Peter

--
Want another angle on cycling? Read my Cycling Blog at www.OregonLive.com/weblogs/bikeblog/

-------------- Original message --------------
From: "Candi Murray"

> Bill Would OK Drunks on Bikes
> By JOE KAFKA
> AP
> PIERRE, South Dakota (Feb. 2) - South Dakota lawmakers decided Wednesday
> that it's better to have drunks on horses and bicycles instead of behind the
> wheel of an auto or truck.
>
>
> The state Senate Judiciary Committee approved a bill 6-1 that will exempt
> horses and bikes from drunken driving laws, meaning intoxicated people who
> either pedal or saddle up to get home after a night at the bar cannot be
> arrested for drunken driving.
>
>
> Sen. Lee Schoenbeck said it will make the roads safer for other motorists.
>
>
> "If I have to choose ... a problem drunk with 1,500 pound or 2,000 pounds of
> met al coming at 50 miles an hour or a two-wheel Schwinn, I'm going to win
> and my family is going to win," he said. "I'd much rather have a drunk on
> the bike."
>
>
> A former lawman, Sen. Gene Abdallah, agreed. Better to have drunks on bikes
> and horses than motor vehicles, he said.
>
>
> "I can't believe that a horse is going to intentionally run into anything,"
> Abdallah said. "This is a good avenue to get some people home."
>
>
> Prosecutors opposed the bill. Chuck Schroyer, lobbyist for the State's
> Attorneys Association, said there have been arrests in several counties for
> riding horses while intoxicated.
>
>
> In one instance, a drunken rider passed out and his horse was struck by a
> car, injuring several people, Schroyer said.
>
>
> "There are people that are injured that are in control of these
> instru ments," he said. "This does happen in the real world."
>
>
> Legislators, however, said prosecutors still can charge drunken riders on
> horses and bicycles. Rather than drunken driving, they can be charged with
> disorderly conduct, it was suggested.
>
> Candi Murray
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> OBRA mailing list
> obra@list.obra.org
> http://list.obra.org/mailman/listinfo/obra


oregonyankee@comcast.net

2006-02-04

So let's all get plastered and weave our bikes down Burnside with impunity! The mind boggles.

Peter

--
Want another angle on cycling? Read my Cycling Blog at www.OregonLive.com/weblogs/bikeblog/

-------------- Original message --------------
From: "Candi Murray"

> Bill Would OK Drunks on Bikes
> By JOE KAFKA
> AP
> PIERRE, South Dakota (Feb. 2) - South Dakota lawmakers decided Wednesday
> that it's better to have drunks on horses and bicycles instead of behind the
> wheel of an auto or truck.
>
>
> The state Senate Judiciary Committee approved a bill 6-1 that will exempt
> horses and bikes from drunken driving laws, meaning intoxicated people who
> either pedal or saddle up to get home after a night at the bar cannot be
> arrested for drunken driving.
>
>
> Sen. Lee Schoenbeck said it will make the roads safer for other motorists.
>
>
> "If I have to choose ... a problem drunk with 1,500 pound or 2,000 pounds of
> metal coming at 50 miles an hour or a two-wheel Schwinn, I'm going to win
> and my family is going to win," he said. "I'd much rather have a drunk on
> the bike."
>
>
> A former lawman, Sen. Gene Abdallah, agreed. Better to have drunks on bikes
> and horses than motor vehicles, he said.
>
>
> "I can't believe that a horse is going to intentionally run into anything,"
> Abdallah said. "This is a good avenue to get some people home."
>
>
> Prosecutors opposed the bill. Chuck Schroyer, lobbyist for the State's
> Attorneys Association, said there have been arrests in several counties for
> riding horses while intoxicated.
>
>
> In one instance, a drunken rider passed out and his horse was struck by a
> car, injuring several people, Schroyer said.
>
>
> "There are people that are injured that are in control of these
> instruments," he said. "This does happen in the real world."
>
>
> Legislators, however, said prosecutors still can charge drunken riders on
> horses and bicycles. Rather than drunken driving, they can be charged with
> disorderly conduct, it was suggested.
>
> Candi Murray
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> OBRA mailing list
> obra@list.obra.org
> http://list.obra.org/mailman/listinfo/obra


Candi Murray

2006-02-04

Bill Would OK Drunks on Bikes
By JOE KAFKA
AP
PIERRE, South Dakota (Feb. 2) - South Dakota lawmakers decided Wednesday
that it's better to have drunks on horses and bicycles instead of behind the
wheel of an auto or truck.

The state Senate Judiciary Committee approved a bill 6-1 that will exempt
horses and bikes from drunken driving laws, meaning intoxicated people who
either pedal or saddle up to get home after a night at the bar cannot be
arrested for drunken driving.

Sen. Lee Schoenbeck said it will make the roads safer for other motorists.

"If I have to choose ... a problem drunk with 1,500 pound or 2,000 pounds of
metal coming at 50 miles an hour or a two-wheel Schwinn, I'm going to win
and my family is going to win," he said. "I'd much rather have a drunk on
the bike."

A former lawman, Sen. Gene Abdallah, agreed. Better to have drunks on bikes
and horses than motor vehicles, he said.

"I can't believe that a horse is going to intentionally run into anything,"
Abdallah said. "This is a good avenue to get some people home."

Prosecutors opposed the bill. Chuck Schroyer, lobbyist for the State's
Attorneys Association, said there have been arrests in several counties for
riding horses while intoxicated.

In one instance, a drunken rider passed out and his horse was struck by a
car, injuring several people, Schroyer said.

"There are people that are injured that are in control of these
instruments," he said. "This does happen in the real world."

Legislators, however, said prosecutors still can charge drunken riders on
horses and bicycles. Rather than drunken driving, they can be charged with
disorderly conduct, it was suggested.

Candi Murray