Low Heart Rate Question

Derek Darves

2005-02-28



Not knowing anything about your training regimen, your description of

physical symptoms sounds like someone who is approaching the deeper

stages of over-reaching and/or a prolonged imbalance of calories in and

calories out. Barring some other medical condition, a constant sense of

being cold, for me at least, is usually a sign that I am not consuming

enough calories.



Likewise (again, for me), difficulty elevating HR during exercise

usually indicates that I have not incorporated enough recovery into my

training program and/or too much intensity work while not being fully

recovered.



Your resting HR does not seem to low or troublesome, though. Mine is

about 38 when I wake up and in the low forties sitting at the computer

or slowly walking around. I have had an EKG and an ECG in the last year,

and they never said anything negative about my resting pulse. A general

lowering of the pulse is a normal adaptation to endurance training. But,

in my experience it can also indicate a prolonged imbalance of energy

in/out. If you are dieting right now you might want to back off for a

while and see if your resting HR increases.



Also, even though HR Max naturally declines with age, I have heard that

this decline is not always linear, even though the formulas might

suggest that it is (e.g. 220 minus age). In other words, your max HR

might decline a bit one year, and not at all the next. While these are

all possibilities, none of this, of course, rules out some ancillary

medical problem, but I?ll let doctors on the list speak to that...



Good luck,

Derek







chr-@thinairad.com wrote:

 

I have a question about low heart rates. I'm concerned mine is way to

low

and I might have some health problems. It seems everything I read and

compare too says I should be about 20-25 beats higher than I am. I

remember

reading if your heart rate is low or if you have troubles raising it, it

could indicate you are sick. However this has been going on for a

while.

First off I've monitored my heart rate with two different heart rate

monitors and by manually checking my pulse. My roommate watched over

the

process to make sure I wasn't being dumb and missing something. I'm 31

years old, been racing for 3 years. For the first two years of racing I

would be much higher and top out in 190s. It has been in the last year

my

heart rate has dropped to a point of concern.

Now my heart rate continues to be really low on and off the bike. When

I'm

sitting down and walking around for short amounts of time it will stay

between 45-55 bpm. I've seen it as low as 40 while sitting in front of

the

computer. Normal walking (like to the store) is around 65 bpm. When

I'm on

the bike it takes a good 10 minutes for my heart to warm up to around

110-120 while doing an easy spin. On a general training ride I hover

around

135. When I'm at top speed, way past lactic threshold, it tops out

around

165ish.

Couple other oddities. I hardly ever sweat, and I'm usually cold. I've

made sure hydration is not an issue.

Any medical people have comments or more seasoned riders have

experienced

something similar.

Thanks to all who read and reply,

Chris Browning



chr-@thinairad.com

2005-02-28



Thank you to everybody (about 20) who responded quickly. I'm posting

feedback because many of you asked for it.



Good news nothing seems wrong. A large number of replies had similar

results, and for about 1/2 of those they also wondered if something was

different with themselves. Like in all things everybody is not the same.



Many also commented on also being cold. One person pointed out being cold

and not sweating had to do with low body fat.



I'll pass this last comment along from several people. They pointed out I

should only ask a doctor these questions and to have it checked out if I had

concerns.



Chris



-----Original Message-----

From: chr-@thinairad.com [mailto:chr-@thinairad.com]

Sent: Monday, February 28, 2005 10:29 AM

To: ob-@topica.com

Subject: [OBRA Chat] Low Heart Rate Question



I have a question about low heart rates. I'm concerned mine is way to low

and I might have some health problems. It seems everything I read and

compare too says I should be about 20-25 beats higher than I am. I remember

reading if your heart rate is low or if you have troubles raising it, it

could indicate you are sick. However this has been going on for a while.

First off I've monitored my heart rate with two different heart rate

monitors and by manually checking my pulse. My roommate watched over the

process to make sure I wasn't being dumb and missing something. I'm 31

years old, been racing for 3 years. For the first two years of racing I

would be much higher and top out in 190s. It has been in the last year my

heart rate has dropped to a point of concern.

Now my heart rate continues to be really low on and off the bike. When I'm

sitting down and walking around for short amounts of time it will stay

between 45-55 bpm. I've seen it as low as 40 while sitting in front of the

computer. Normal walking (like to the store) is around 65 bpm. When I'm on

the bike it takes a good 10 minutes for my heart to warm up to around

110-120 while doing an easy spin. On a general training ride I hover around

135. When I'm at top speed, way past lactic threshold, it tops out around

165ish.

Couple other oddities. I hardly ever sweat, and I'm usually cold. I've

made sure hydration is not an issue.

Any medical people have comments or more seasoned riders have experienced

something similar.

Thanks to all who read and reply,

Chris Browning



To respond to the whole group send to ob-@topica.com.

To respond to the list manager send to cmur-@obra.org

To unsubscribe send to obra-uns-@topica.com



chr-@thinairad.com

2005-02-28



I have a question about low heart rates. I'm concerned mine is way to low

and I might have some health problems. It seems everything I read and

compare too says I should be about 20-25 beats higher than I am. I remember

reading if your heart rate is low or if you have troubles raising it, it

could indicate you are sick. However this has been going on for a while.

First off I've monitored my heart rate with two different heart rate

monitors and by manually checking my pulse. My roommate watched over the

process to make sure I wasn't being dumb and missing something. I'm 31

years old, been racing for 3 years. For the first two years of racing I

would be much higher and top out in 190s. It has been in the last year my

heart rate has dropped to a point of concern.

Now my heart rate continues to be really low on and off the bike. When I'm

sitting down and walking around for short amounts of time it will stay

between 45-55 bpm. I've seen it as low as 40 while sitting in front of the

computer. Normal walking (like to the store) is around 65 bpm. When I'm on

the bike it takes a good 10 minutes for my heart to warm up to around

110-120 while doing an easy spin. On a general training ride I hover around

135. When I'm at top speed, way past lactic threshold, it tops out around

165ish.

Couple other oddities. I hardly ever sweat, and I'm usually cold. I've

made sure hydration is not an issue.

Any medical people have comments or more seasoned riders have experienced

something similar.

Thanks to all who read and reply,

Chris Browning